Meet Mermaid Shelly!
Welp, did the best I could with what I had around the house. Luckily when my mom asked "why do you need tape" and I responded with "well, there's this SA mod challenge involving a mermaid costume..." all she said was "Take the damn tape, bring it back, and show me the picture if you win."
(A debate regarding the "blunts" modeled by Kit Walker and Lolitas Alright! ensues. TheJoker138 sets us straight.)